What difference does a heat pump make in a car?

Electric cars have ushered in a new era of innovation, with brands regularly updating vehicles to feature all kinds of modern technology. 

If you are looking for more details, kindly visit Heat Pump in Car.

That includes lots of technology to improve the range of modern EVs, such as regenerative braking. That takes the kinetic energy that would be lost by a car slowing down and feed it back into the battery.

The latest electric vehicle news in your inbox: get our FREE newsletter

One of the most notable bits of new technology helping to boost the range of an EV &#; particularly in winter &#; is a heat pump. Now an optional extra on many EVs, heat pumps retain heat from the batteries and use it to increase the range of an EV. 

Here we explain how heat pumps work, how they benefit your electric car and how much they cost as an optional extra. 

How does a heat pump work?

Motors, whether electric or combustion engine, produce heat when they're used. That's effectively wasted energy, so in an attempt to make the most of it combustion engine cars use a small amount of it to help run a car's heating and ventilation.

By comparison, EVs are just too efficient for their own good: while the motors and batteries do produce excess heat that can harm the range, there isn't enough to be used for the ventilation system. So EV drivers either go cold, or have to draw extra power from the battery to operate a fan heater. Not ideal.

That's where a heat pump comes in. It&#;s effectively a refrigerator but in reverse: its function is the opposite of the one found in your kitchen.

A household fridge contains refrigerant gas which becomes hot when compressed. Once compressed the gas is transported around a number of tubes to the condenser. 

The condenser then radiates the heat out, thus cooling the refrigerant gas which then travels into a grid called the evaporator. Because the evaporator is larger than the condenser, the pressure drops and the liquid refrigerant is evaporated. The temperature then drops and the fridge is cooled. 

An EV heat pump draws air in from outside, compresses it, then uses the heat from the condenser to raise the temperature in either the battery or the car's interior.                                                                       

Reversible heat pumps can also warm, as well as cool, the battery. If cooling, any excess heat from the battery can be sent to the inside via the cabin heater. 

Does it increase the range of an EV?

Adding a heat pump has many benefits, but most importantly is its ability to increase the range of your electric car, particularly during the winter months. 

When an electric car is switched on in winter months, it takes longer for the battery to warm up which reduces efficiency. The lithium-ion batteries in an EV rely on chemical reactions to store and create electricity. Cold weather slows these reactions down resulting in the drop in performance and range. 

It is estimated that EVs range drops by around 10 per cent in winter, even before you account for using extra energy for cabin heating. Heat pumps can really help reduce that drop-off.

During our winter real-world range test &#; conducted in partnership with sister brand What Car? &#; the electric cars fitted with a heat pump fell short of their official range by an average of 25.4 per cent, while those without suffered a 33.6 per cent deficit. 

Cars with heat pumps also proved more efficient, averaging 3.2 miles/kWh, compared with 2.9 miles/kWh for ones without. 

In addition, heat pumps are often programmed to be remotely controlled by your smartphone, allowing EV owners to heat their car before they set off on a journey. And if you&#;re plugged into the mains electricity you won&#;t drain the battery either. 

Do heat pumps come as standard?

Heat pumps becoming more popular, and some brand such as Tesla, Porsche and BMW offer EVs with such devices as standard. Some manufacturers offer a heat pump as an optional extra, and frustratingly they can be a pricey addition. 

The Hyundai Ioniq 5, for example, offers a heat pump as an optional extra for £995. Skoda asks for £ for a heat pump for the Enyaq iV. It is worth noting that heat pumps are often included in the kit list for higher trim levels of many models.

Even if they are an expensive option, a heat pump is worth considering: they have extensive benefits, from improving efficiency, to increasing the range of your EV. 

Whether you&#;re thinking of making the switch to an EV or about to order your new set of zero-emission wheels, we&#;d recommend adding a heat pump for peace of mind. 

READ MORE

Subscribe to the Move Electric newsletter

e-CARS

E-cars news and reviews

Living with a Citroën Ami

Ten electric cars we're excited for in

Getting an EV sideways: how easy is it to drift a Kia EV6 GT?

Q&A: Jaguar Racing's Sam Bird and Mitch Evans on Formula E's new era

e-BIKES

E-bike reviews and news

Ten electric bikes we're excited for in

Can you get fit using an electric bike?

The company is the world’s best Thermistor Suppliers supplier. We are your one-stop shop for all needs. Our staff are highly-specialized and will help you find the product you need.

Recommended article:
FAQs about Air Chambers
How to Choose best wine coolers and cigar humidors supplier?
Common Questions We're Asked About Wine Coolers

Gocycle G4i e-bike review

e-MOTORBIKES

E-motorbike reviews and news

Ten electric motorbikes we're excited for in

Super Soco TC Max electric motorbike review

Cake and Polestar team up for new special edition Makka e-motorbike

e-SCOOTERS

E-scooter news and reviews

Planned laws to legalise private e-scooters face delay

Five key takeaways from the rental e-scooter trials report

Which train firms have banned e-scooters from their services?

e-WORLD

E-world news

Move Electric's best features of : lap records, tuk-tuks&#; and sausage rolls

Volvo Trucks keeps on electric trucking with three new models

VIDEO: Watch Move Electric's epic e-race across London

 

Want to dive into the science and learn how much they really help your cold weather range?

Heaters in ICE vehicles

Have you ever put your hand on the hood of a car after it got off the highway or finished a long drive? It&#;s hot! This is because traditional gasoline engines are very inefficient - 75%-85% of the energy produced is lost to heat! The nice thing is that in the winter, some of this waste heat can be directed into the vehicle to heat the cabin and keep the driver and passengers toasty warm. 

image by Karin Kirk for Yale Climate Connections with data from fueleconomy.gov

Provided that EVs do not have engines, and have drivetrain efficiency of around 80%, very little waste heat is produced, so cabin warming has to happen another way.

Many groups have shown that the climate control systems (heating and air conditioning; HVAC) are the largest energy consumption system in an EV, with several studies showing that a driver can expect to lose an average of 30-40% driving range with conventional HVAC systems. Recurrent found that in 100+ degree weather, air conditioning can cut range by up to 30%, and heating a car in freezing weather can drop range by more than 40%. Another study showed the range reduction was up to ~16% for cooling and ~50% for heating, depending on conditions and drive cycle. Since range anxiety is a major issue preventing widespread EV adoption, it&#;s crucial that car makers modernize HVAC systems to be more efficient.

How do EV Heaters Work?

Given that EVs have almost no waste heat that can be shuttled into the cabin, EVs rely entirely on electricity to produce heat, which can be broken into two major categories: resistive heating, and heat pumps. 

1. Resistive heating - Similar to a space heater for your home. Electricity is run through a conductor to produce heat, and that heat is directed into the cabin via a fan. Although nearly 100% of the energy used is converted into heat, it is an energy-intensive process. If you are pulling energy from the battery to turn into heat, it will be a direct hit to your range. One specific type of resistive heater used in cars is a PTC heater, which comes up in the studies below. 
2. Heat pump - This method is very similar to air conditioning, but inverted. Air is drawn from the outside and run through a condenser that contains refrigerant. This solution is compressed, which raises the temperature, allowing for hot air to be pumped into the cabin. This process, while also energy intensive, is much more efficient. 

Measuring and comparing the energy efficiency of heat pumps vs. resistive heaters has been a major topic of interest with EV drivers in the past few years, so we hope to shed some light based on the best available research. 

Range Effect of Resistive Heaters

The no-brainer approach to an EV heat and cooling system is to use the same technology that has been done in ICE cars forever: use a resistive heater and an electric refrigerant compressor for cooling. The heater itself is cheap, simple, and nearly 100% efficient, meaning all electricity is converted into heat. However, while this method is effective, it is not very efficient in terms of overall vehicle energy consumption. The average vehicle needs 4-8 kW of heating and cooling capacity, depending on interior volume, amount of exposed glass, insulation, and ambient temperature. Therefore, using a resistive heater means a direct of 4-8kW draw on the battery, in addition to energy used for the drivetrain. Depending on the difference between the outside temperature and the desired cabin temperature, range losses of up to 50% have been observed. Recurrent&#;s winter weather update showed a possible range loss of 45% at only 32F.

Let&#;s use some real world data from my Chevrolet Bolt EV for context. On a relatively flat stretch of road at moderate temperatures (no HVAC needed,~80F), the Bolt requires ~16kW of power to maintain 65 mph, which puts the efficiency around 4.06 miles/kWh. If it&#;s cold enough that I need to use the heater at full capacity, that power demand increases to 24kW at 65 mph, with an efficiency of 2.71 miles/kWh. 

Across the entire 65kWh battery, this reduces our effective range from ~264 miles to ~176 miles, a reduction of 33%. 

Even if you figure that you can turn down the heat once the cabin is warm, the range will still drop 20% to 211 miles. 

But What About Heat Pumps?

While a resistive heater is 100% efficient at generating heat from electricity, the process is still relatively inefficient because heat must be converted from another energy source. A heat pump, on the other hand, uses electricity to move heat from one place to another. To do this, heat pumps use a reverse refrigeration cycle to bring in heat from the outside air that has been boosted in temperature by a reverse refrigeration cycle. 

If we want to compare efficiency between a heat pump and a resistive heater, we need to use a concept called the coefficient of performance (COP), which is the ratio of the heat produced and transferred to the cabin vs. the energy required to make and move that heat. And this is where it gets interesting: while the net efficiency of a traditional heat pump is quite low (~50% at ambient temperatures), it can produce heat using less energy. The COP of a heat pump can reach 3 or 4, meaning 3-4 units of heat are transferred for every 1 unit of electricity used. Meanwhile, the resistive heater, which turns 100% of energy into heat, has a COP of 1. The heat pump is 3-4 times more efficient.

Not Just for Cars

Heat pumps are not unique to vehicles, and have emerged as a promising tool in the global transition toward clean and reliable energy, specifically in cold climates. One study found that well below 32°F, heat pump efficiency is still significantly higher than resistive heating systems at an appliance level. The heat pumps investigated in the study demonstrated efficient heating during cold winters where temperatures rarely fall below 14°F. Even in extreme climates, with temperatures near -20°F, heat pump may provide heat at efficiencies up to double that of resistive heating. 

Image from Engtiger47, CC BY-SA 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0>, via Wikimedia Commons

Let&#;s go back to the Bolt EV example and assume we have a heat pump with a COP of 3 while heating. The draw for heating in this case is reduced to 1.33-2.67kW, implying a total demand of 17.3-18.67kW when traveling at 65 mph with the heat on. This results in an effective vehicle efficiency of 3.5-3.7 miles/kWh. It leaves us with a range of around 230 miles, only a 10-14% decrease from baseline.

In agreement with this data, in early , a UK-based company performed real-world winter range testing of several popular EV models, revealing that &#;models equipped with a heat pump fell short by an average of 25.4% from their official figures, compared with the 33.6% deficit suffered by those that relied on a regular interior heater.&#; Vehicles with heat pumps equipped averaged 3.2 miles/kWh, while those with resistive (or PCT-based) heaters averaged 2.9 miles/kWh. 

Emerging Research: vehicle range loss with different heaters

One of the big topics of debate on EV forums (and energy efficiency forums, in general) is if there is a temperature at which heat pumps stop being more efficient than resistive heaters. For instance, a popular comment is that in Canadian and Northern US winters, a heat pump will not produce enough heat, or will not save you any range above a traditional, resistive heater. 

While Recurrent lacks sufficient really cold weather data to confirm or deny these claims, we have aggregated existing data on the efficiency of heat pumps and resistive heaters in different temperatures. Below are summary results from several studies that compare heat pump vs PTC resistive heater in freezing and below-freezing conditions. Note that a PTC heater stands for positive temperature coefficient heater, the type of resistive heater commonly found in cars. 

Below, we show that in two studies, heat pumps have significant range benefits in cold weather as compared to a resistance heater. While the range savings is more pronounced at 32°F, both studies show a range benefit at 14°F.

The data for this chart is taken from Kang Li et at. "Investigation on the performance and characteristics of a heat pump system for electric vehicles under extreme temperature conditions" and a NREL study.

A paper, Zhao C, Li Y, Yang Y, et al. Research on electric vehicle range under cold condition, compared a resistance heater and a heat pump at 20°F against a baseline testing at 77°F. This research found a total range loss of 42.8% with a traditional PTC heater, of which 26.4% was attributed to resistive heating alone. The remainder of range loss came from a deterioration in battery performance and a reduction in drivetrain efficiency. Meanwhile a heat pump showed only a 31% reduction in energy consumption, resulting in a 7.9% increase in range, compared to the resistance PTC heater. The average power demand was 1.6kW with PCT, 1.1kW with the heat pump. 

Similarly, at 14°F, Experimental Investigation on Heating Performance of Newly Designed Air Source Heat Pump System for Electric Vehicles showed an increase in the driving range with a heat pump by 25&#;31% when compared to PTC resistance heater. 

Finally, this NREL study compared the range loss from baseline with a PTC resistance heater and a heat pump across a range of temperatures. 

For PTC-only heating, the vehicle range loss varies from 28.3% to 53.8%. When operating the heat pump system, the recovered vehicle range varies from 12.8% to only 1.1%. This data indicates that the heat pump system provides a very large energy efficiency benefit for mild heating conditions, but becomes ineffective compared to the PTC heater at extremely low temperatures.

One potential way to improve the low-temperature performance would be to use a larger capacity compressor to offset more of the supplemental PTC heating. Additionally, the inclusion of waste heat recovery can provide an additional 1.5% to 2% under all conditions. While this is a moderate benefit when compared with the heat pump at mild temperatures, at colder temperatures, it becomes a valuable contribution. 

Finally, it is important to consider how quickly you need to warm up the cabin and how warm you need to get it. For example, the study above uses a system in which the cabin temperature increases from 28°F to 72°F in 23 minutes. Dramatically different results are seen when you raise the temperature to more modest temperatures (e.g. 60°F), or use a compressor that takes less time to heat the cabin. 

Want more information on What Does Ptc Stand for in Electronics? Feel free to contact us.